Skip to main content

Table 1 Basic characteristics of the included articles

From: Adverse events of intestinal microbiota transplantation in randomized controlled trials: a systematic review and meta-analysis

References

Country

Study design

Disease

Route of delivery

Follow up

Donor source

Antibiotics use before IMT

Preparation

Stool sample dose

Fresh or frozen

Frequency of IMT

Cammarota et al. [33]

Italy

Open-label RCT

rCDI

Colonoscopy

10 weeks

Healthy volunteers related or unrelated

Vancomycin

4 L macrogol

50 ml solution

Fresh

Fecal infusion every 3 days

Moayyedi et al. [34]

Canada

Double-blind RCT

UC

Enema

12 months

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

50 g

Fresh

once per week for 6 weeks

Rossen et al. [35]

Netherlands

Double-blind RCT

UC

Nasoduodenal tube

12 weeks

Healthy partners, relatives or volunteers

NR

2 L macrogol

NR

Fresh

 × 2

Kelly et al. [36]

USA

Double-blind RCT

rCDI

Colonoscopy

6 months

Healthy volunteers

Vancomycin

Sodium sulfate, potassium sulfate, magnesium sulfate

64 g

Fresh

 × 1

Bajaj et al. [37]

USA

Open-label RCT

Hepatic encephalopathy

Enema

150 days

Healthy volunteers

Metronidazole, ciprofloxacin, amoxicillin

NR

90 ml

Frozen

 × 1

Hota et al. [38]

Canada

Open-label RCT

rCDI

Enema

120 days

Healthy volunteers

Vancomycin

NR

50 g

Fresh

 × 1

Paramsothy et al. [39]

Australia

Double-blind RCT

UC

Enema

8 weeks

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

37.5 g

Frozen

 × 5 per week for 8 weeks

Tian et al. [40]

China

Single-blind RCT

Constipation

Nasointestinal tube

12 weeks

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

100 g

Frozen

many times

Halkjær et al. [12]

Denmark

Double-blind RCT

IBS

Capsules

6 months

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

50 g

Frozen

25 capsules per day for 12 days

Johnsen et al. [13]

Norway

Double-blind RCT

IBS

Colonoscopy

12 months

Healthy volunteers

No antibiotics were given

Sodium picosulphate plus magnesium citrate

50–80 g

Fresh

 × 1

Aroniadis et al. [14]

USA

Double-blind RCT

IBS-D

Capsules

24 weeks

Healthy volunteers

NR

PPI

9.5 g

Frozen

×3

Costello et al. [41]

Australia

Double-blind RCT

UC

Colonoscopy

12 months

Healthy volunteers

NR

Polyethylene glycol and loperamide

100 g

Frozen

×3

Huttner et al. [42]

France

Open-label RCT

Multidrug-resistant Enterobacteriaceae

Capsules or nasogastric

30 weeks

Healthy volunteers

Colistin and neomycin

PPI

40 g

Frozen

×2

Hvas et al. [43]

Denmark

Open-label RCT

rCDI

Colonoscopy or nasojejunal tube

8 weeks

Healthy volunteers

Vancomycin

Standard lavage

50 g

Frozen

×1

Sood et al. [44]

India

Double-blind RCT

UC

Colonoscopy

48 weeks

Healthy volunteers

NR

Polyethylene glycol

100 g

Frozen

×1 every 8 weeks for 48 weeks

Allegretti, et al. [23]

USA

Double-blind RCT

Obese

Capsules

12 weeks

Healthy lean donors

No antibiotics

PPI;No bowel preparation

22.5 g, 9 g, 9 g (week0, 4, 8)

Frozen

×3

Bajaj et al. [37]

USA

Double-blind RCT

Alcohol use disorder

Enema

6 months

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

27 g

NR

×1

El-Salhy et al. [46]

Norway

Double-blind RCT

IBS

Gastroscope

3 months

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

30 g, 60 g

Frozen

×1

Fretheim et al. [24]

Norway

Double-blind RCT

Systemic sclerosis

Gastroscope

16 weeks

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

NR

Frozen

×1

Lahtinen et al. [47]

Finland

Double-blind RCT

IBS

Colonoscopy

52 weeks

Healthy volunteers

NR

NR

NR

Frozen

×1

Yu et al. [48]

USA

Double-blind RCT

Metabolism in obesity

Capsules

12 weeks

Healthy lean donors

NR

NR

Total 105 capsules

Frozen

×2 first week×1/week for 5 weeks

  1. IMT intestinal microbiota transplantation, RCT randomized controlled trial, rCDI recurrent Clostridioides difficile infection, NR not reported, IBS Inflammatory Bowel Disease, UC Ulcerative colitis, PPI proton pump inhibitor